Pleasant Hill Grain


Shopping Basket

  • This item was added
  • items in your basket
  • (close)

Talk to a Product Expert!   (866) 467-6123 or chat

Blueberry Butter Bay dish with butter.
Choosing a drop-down option makes more images available.
click for
This item ships free! Your order could ship free!

Why Buy from PHG?

  • Quality, curated product selection
  • Prompt, personal customer service
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
Accepted credit cards
Canadian orders by phone! Canadian orders by phone
SKU: XA474
  • $29.95
  • In Stock Usually ships in 1-2 business days.


  • Keeps butter fresh & spreadable
  • Holds 1/2-cup of butter
  • Perfectly shaped for Western butter cubes
  • Available in five colors
  • Made in the USA


Butter Bay Butter Keeper Dish

Butter Bay butter keepers are a great way to store butter so it will stay soft and spreadable. A 1/2-cup cube or stick of butter fits perfectly inside the cup part of the Butter Bay, and when the cup is turned upside down into the base of cool water an airtight seal is formed. For best results, change the water every 3-4 days. Each Butter Bay is made using the slip-cast method, and kiln-fired in a factory that was built in the early 1900s.

  • “I've used your product in my home for many years and love the concept... was super excited when I saw the new and improved version... I ordered two so I would have one ready to go for our new camper!”

    – Patricia S., IL

Butter Bay butter keepers are available in colors of Blueberry Blue, Licorice Black, Oatmeal Beige, Pomegranate Red, and Sunshine Yellow.

Watch the video above to see how Butter Bay butter keepers work!

How to fill Butter Bay


Did we forget something? If you need more information about this product, please tell us what else you'd like to know with a quick email or live chat!


Select product option(s) from the drop-down menu at top of page to see item-specific specifications here.

Brand Butter Bay
Length 6.3"
Width 3.4"
Height 3.2"
Product Weight 11 oz
Material Stoneware
Capacity 1/2 cup
UPC Does not apply
Origin USA

Use & Care

Dishwasher safe.


Select product option(s) from the drop-down menu at top of page to see item-specific specifications here.



Overall Rating:
13 Reviews
Viewing 1 - 10 of 13
  • View:
  • 10
  • 20
  • 50
  • Butter Keeper
    By on - Verified Buyer
    After 3 months I'm still satisfied with my butter dish.
    4 out of 4 people found this review helpful.  Did you?
  • Love this
    By on - Verified Buyer
    I love having my butter soft so that I can use it without having to remember to get it out early enough for it to soften before I need it.
    1 person found this review helpful.  Did you?
  • Awesome
    By on - Verified Buyer
    This butter keeper is awesome
    1 person found this review helpful.  Did you?
  • Butter keeper
    By on - Verified Buyer
    Very prompt service and a great product.
    1 person found this review helpful.  Did you?
  • good and bad
    By on - Verified Buyer
    Summer now, butter liquifies in my kitchen at room temperature and the ants find it. I'm looking for alternates with less saturated fat than butter. I'm not using it. In winter, when I bake bread, it works well. I bought it on a whim.
    1 person didn't find this review helpful.  Did you?
  • Great product and great Customer Service
    By on - Verified Buyer
    Awesome product and remarkably, it works as advertised. The customer service at Pleasant Hill is just as remarkable. They actually called prior to shipping to ensure that my order was actually correct. Very pleasant lady and obviously customer satisfaction oriented which believe it or not it’s not (it should) but it’s not found in all CS.
    Was this review helpful to you?
  • Safe butter keeper
    By on - Verified Buyer
    I was looking for a made in the USA butter keeper to enjoy soft spreading butter. It also had to be lead and cadmium free. This product met those requirements. Beyond that I had fine customer service, a very well packaged product for shipping safely, and prompt delivery. I can think of no reason to order from anyone else! These folks are friendly and excellent with many attractive products.
    Was this review helpful to you?
  • Finally a great butter container!
    By on - Verified Buyer
    Six months ago I purchased this sturdy, well made, beautifully glazed butter container. Made in the USA, not China. My husband and I love it. I bought two more for gifts (requested). Wish my Dad was still alive to use it, as he always complained about the poor design of the old butter containers.
    Was this review helpful to you?
  • Practical and easy
    By on - Verified Buyer
    I used to have a “traditional” shaped butter bell (round cup) but gave it way because filling the bell with butter was messy. When a friend with a birthday coming up mentioned that’s the same reason she didn’t use one I immediately ordered two - one is wrapped up to give my friend for her birthday gift.
    Was this review helpful to you?
  • Butter Bay
    By on - Verified Buyer
    The butter keeper itself is sleek and beautiful!! We love how this product works, although there is a "learning curve"... we have to make sure the butter seals every time we use it or it drops down in the water.

    Barbara, we find it helps to smear a thin film of butter into the bell first, if you're encountering that problem. Solves it for us! Thanks for your review!

    Was this review helpful to you?
  1. 1
  2. 2

See product description below.

Return to top
Back to top